I’m totally loving this coconut custard pie recipe. Various versions of this classic pie have been around for a while, but when testing them, I was a little disappointed. The textures were funky, they were over the top on the shredded coconut, or the eggs scrambled. There was rarely much “custard” to be found and they weren’t something I’d bake again. They definitely didn’t meet the idea I had in my head.

I decided to take a page from my honey pie recipe and partially cook the custard on the stove, before finishing it in the oven. So this recipe actually begins with that honey pie recipe, with some changes, of course. If you’ve ever made that pie – and you should, it’s one of my absolute favorites – then you know that the texture of this pie is amazing. This is a true custard-based pie with coconut flavor that’s not too much, and shredded coconut that complements the custard, rather than taking it over. It’s so good and is the new way you should make coconut custard pie.

I really enjoy a good lemon meringue pie. The tart, but also sweet, lemon filling with the light meringue and the crisp, buttery crust is a heavenly combination. But meringue can be finicky and is the defining piece that determines a great pie, or a soupy pie. I did alllll the testing so that you can have it turn out right every time!

This pie uses the more traditional French meringue topping, but it is fully baked. While French meringue can be finicky and will eventually begin to weep a bit, if done correctly it can actually hold up really well for several days. The key to a stable meringue that doesn’t immediately weep is to use cream of tartar, a little cornstarch, and to cook it fully.

And if you want a truly reliable meringue that won’t weep at all, you can go with a Swiss meringue. It’s what I use on my Lemon Meringue Cheesecake. It’s delicious and I love it, but it has more of a marshmallow-y flavor to it, which I personally think can overpower this pie a bit. But it is super reliable!

Lovers of banana cream pie, I have a feeling you’ll love this coconut cream pie! It has a super smooth and creamy texture, and the flavor is just right. Why, you ask? While this pie filling could be made with just whole milk and coconut milk, the sweetened condensed milk takes it to another level. The additional flavor and creaminess it adds are truly on point. You get less egg flavor, more sweetness, and more creaminess. 

I also chose to use just egg yolks, rather than just whole eggs. After doing a side-by-side comparison, it was clear that the yolks gave the pie a smoother texture and richer flavor. Whole eggs made the filling a bit more gelatinous. Between the sweetened condensed milk and egg yolks, this pie is a winner!

The idea for this banana pudding pie came about while testing some updates to my banana cream pie. I tested that filling with a few different milk combinations, including some sweetened condensed milk. I loved the version of the filling with sweetened condensed milk, but in trying to stick with a more traditional filling for that pie, I decided not to use that version for that pie.

However, it was too good not to use it for something! I really love banana pudding that is made with sweetened condensed milk, so it seemed natural to bring that filling into a banana pudding pie layered with banana slices and Nilla wafers. It was an amazing decision because this pie turned out even better than I imagined, and it is so good!

As much as I love my other banana pudding-inspired desserts, like banana pudding poke cake, I am kind of obsessed with this pie. It’s just so darn good! If you love banana pudding as much as me, this pie will be your jam.